Summary
Given the success of the franchise as a whole, it is no wonder that so much fan-led discussion takes place aroundRed Dead Redemption 3, despite the game not even being officially confirmed. There is a huge range of potential narrative threads, settings, and characters that the title could explore, creating its own identity while paying homage to its predecessors.
It is clear thatRed Dead Redemption 3would have to take some bold measures to stand out againstRed Dead Redemption 2, and the title could be the perfect time to break one longstanding tradition that the past two games famously employed. With the previous twoRed Deadprotagonists meeting brutal and cruel ends, a third game would be wise to break the cycle and finally give fans redemption that they can be happy about.
RELATED:Red Dead Redemption 2 Calculations Reveal the Stunning Modern Fortune Left in Blackwater
While theenvironments and atmosphere of theRed Deadfranchiseare a huge point of appeal for many players, the characters within them are what really make the games tick. The likes of John Marston and Arthur Morgan have gone down as some of the most beloved and complex protagonists across the gaming industry as a whole, with their stories being as endearing as they are tragic.
The lives of both John and Arthur were extremely similar, right down to their untimely demise. Of course, John Marston was famously killed in a shameless double-cross withinRed Dead Redemption’s shocking ending, while players had to watch as Arthur Morgan slowly succumbed to his battle with tuberculosis throughout the later events ofRed Dead Redemption 2. This gave the endings of both titles serious weight and memorability, forcing players to really think about the consequences of the game’s narratives and the long-lasting impact they have on the characters within them.
While the deaths of John and Arthur played well intotheRed Deadthemes of the Old West dying, it is time for the franchise to give its next protagonist a more uplifting end to their character arc. IfRed Dead 3’s main character was to meet the same fate as John and Arthur, the franchise would fall into the trappings of predictable endings, and a death like this may not be the best fit for the themes thatRDR3will likely explore.
Many have assumed that the story and setting ofRed Dead Redemption 3will have to look to the future instead of the past, with the end of the Wild West already being thoroughly explored. There is room for the franchise to do this if it uses Jack Marston as its main protagonist, telling the tale of Jack after avenging his father while having to deal with a rapidly changing world and the fallout of his traumatic childhood.
This setting would sadly lose the cowboy-centric traits of past games, but could stillexplore things like the First World Warand the new breed of “outlaw” gangsters in the 1920s. Killing Jack at the end of such a title would be a big misstep when considering the sacrifices that John and Arthur made to ensure that Jack lived a more fulfilling life than themselves. Jack is essentially living proof that the actions of pastRDRprotagonists were worth something, and his survival in a potentialRed Dead Redemption 3could be the best way to ultimately portray a meaningful redemption for all three characters.
MORE:Funny Red Dead Redemption 2 Image Shows How Much Better Arthur is Than John At One Thing
